ARCHIVED
JPN

SUBJECT FILE NO. SA-0054

BUSHI ARCHIVE

Ii Naotora

Ii Naotora

Head of the Ii house; lord of Ii-no-ya in Tōtōmi Province

SECTION I -- SUBJECT PROFILE

NameIi Naotora
EnglishIi Naotora
OriginJapan
Lifespanunknown–1582?
GenderFemale
Century16th C.
Clan / RoleDaimyo
TitleHead of the Ii house; lord of Ii-no-ya in Tōtōmi Province

SECTION II -- OVERVIEW

Year of birth unknown. Born into the Ii house of Ii-no-ya in Tōtōmi Province (the modern Kita Ward of Hamamatsu City, Shizuoka Prefecture); taken as the sole daughter of Ii Naomori.

Her father Naomori fell at the Battle of Okehazama in 1560; his successor Ii Naochika (her cousin) was killed by Imagawa Ujizane in 1562, and the male line of the Ii house was cut off.

According to the Ii Family Records, Naotora — who had taken vows under the name Jirō-hōshi — was set up as head of the Ii house and ruled Ii-no-ya.

But since around 2016, source-critical research has raised the possibility that the person called Jirō-hōshi was in fact Sekiguchi Ujitsune, a male of the Imagawa house, and the traditional 'female castellan Naotora' image has come under reexamination.

From 1568 she entered the protection of Tokugawa Ieyasu, and protected and raised Ii Toramatsu — the orphaned heir of the Ii house, later Ii Naomasa (this site's id 48).

She is said to have died in 1582. The foundation for Toramatsu's Tokugawa service, the restoration of the Ii house, and eventually the Edo-period Hikone domain of 300,000 koku was built in this period.

SECTION III -- CHRONOLOGY

unknownBorn at Ii-no-ya in Tōtōmi Province
1560Her father Ii Naomori falls at Okehazama
1562Her cousin Ii Naochika killed by Imagawa Ujizane
1565?Becomes head of the Ii house (per the Ii Family Records)
1568Enters the protection of Tokugawa Ieyasu
1582Dies (per the Ii Family Records)

SECTION V -- FIELD NOTES

[A]The 'Male Naotora' Argument and the 'Female Castellan' Tradition

From around 2016, source-critical research has been published questioning the very existence of Ii Naotora as a historical person.

The Kanasashi family documents discovered in Kyoto include a record suggesting that the 'Jirō-hōshi' who ruled Ii-no-ya was in fact Sekiguchi Ujitsune (of the Imagawa house), a male; and it has been pointed out that the account of Naotora as a woman in the Ii Family Records may be a construction of Edo-period compilation.

It was actively discussed around the time of the 2017 NHK taiga drama 'Onna Jōshu Naotora' (Lady Warlord Naotora).

The traditional image of Naotora rests on the Ii family tradition and later narrative; the corroboration in contemporary primary sources is limited.

SECTION VI -- LEGACY & IMPACT

The very existence of Naotora has become an object of reexamination in recent years, but the 'female castellan' image transmitted by the Ii Family Records took deep root in the Ii house's consciousness of house honor from the Edo period on, and was handed down through generations as Hikone domain tradition.

Through the 2017 NHK taiga drama 'Lady Warlord Naotora,' the story came to be known overseas as well. At Ryōtan-ji in Ii-no-ya, a site said to be Naotora's grave is transmitted, and is still visited by pilgrims today.

As background to the restoration of the Ii house and the Tokugawa service of Naomasa (this site's id 48), the story of the female lord of Ii-no-ya holds a position in Japanese cultural history that outruns the question of its literal truth.

SECTION VII -- MAJOR DEEDS

  • [01]Rule of Ii-no-ya as head of the Ii house (1565?–1568)
  • [02]Entry into the protection of Tokugawa Ieyasu (1568)
  • [03]Protection and raising of Ii Toramatsu (later Naomasa)
  • [04]Formation of the foundation for the Ii-house restoration

SECTION VIII -- REFERENCE MATERIALS

PRIMARY SOURCES & ARCHIVES

  • PRIMARY

    Ii Family Records

    Transmitted in the Ii family

    Ii-family genealogy compiled in the Edo period; the principal source for the 'female Naotora' account

  • SCHOLARSHIP

    The Life of Ii Naotora

    Owada Tetsuo / Yōsensha

    Representative Naotora study published around 2016 in connection with the taiga drama

  • ARCHIVE

    Ryōtan-ji

    Kita Ward, Hamamatsu City, Shizuoka Prefecture

    Mortuary temple of the Ii house; transmits a site said to be Naotora's grave

    Visit archive →

RECOMMENDED READING

END OF FILE -- SA-0054PAGE 1 OF 1