FIELD REPORTS

The Fall: In 1788, the Reformer Was Buried Under Disgrace

His heir cut down within the castle, saddled with the confusion of the Tenmei famine, Tanuma Okitsugu fell from power with the death of the shōgun. His successor Matsudaira Sadanobu denied all his policies. The reformer ahead of his time was buried by the values of the old order.

Tanuma Okitsugufall from powerKansei Reforms

In 1786 (Tenmei 6), at Edo Castle. The tenth shōgun Tokugawa Ieharu, Tanuma Okitsugu's greatest backing, departed the world.

Immediately after that death, Okitsugu was dismissed from the rōjū and tumbled at a stroke from the seat of power.

His domain of Sagara was confiscated, and his mansion taken. The reformer who had led shogunal government for nearly twenty years, the instant he lost his backing, immediately fell from power.

What awaited Okitsugu was a later life of disgrace and solitude.

The Violent Death of His Heir Okitomo

In 1784, preceding his fall, a deep grief struck Okitsugu. His heir Tanuma Okitomo, who had supported his father as a wakadoshiyori, was slashed by the hatamoto Sano Masakoto within Edo Castle and lost his life.

To suddenly lose, within the castle, the successor to whom he had entrusted the future — for Okitsugu personally, there was no wound greater than this.

The world whispered of this incident as if it were heaven's punishment on the Tanuma's power.

The father's grief, overlapping with political isolation, drove Okitsugu into a corner.

Famine and Backlash

As it happened, the Tenmei years saw a great famine and the eruption of Mt. Asama overlap, and the whole country was visited by hunger and confusion.

Okitsugu's commerce-focused policies were saddled with the blame for such destitution of the people.

In truth the famine was largely a matter of natural disaster, but the people's discontent was directed at the man in power, Tanuma.

The ill fame of bribe-politics too was amplified amid this backlash. Before the fruits of reform could ripen, Okitsugu was swallowed by the headwind of the age.

Reforms Denied

After Okitsugu's fall, it was Matsudaira Sadanobu who took the real power of shogunal government.

Sadanobu's Kansei Reforms denied all of Tanuma's policies and steered toward austerity finances and a return to agrarianism.

The commerce-focused line was buried, and Okitsugu's name was disparaged as the byword for a 'bribe politician.

' In 1788, Okitsugu departed the world in despair. He was seventy. Nearly two centuries would be required before the will of the reformer ahead of his time was justly appraised.

Having lost his heir and been saddled with disgrace, Okitsugu's later years were far too lonely.

"Will the day come when my reforms are rightly understood? Okitomo — it is your father whose regret is deepest."
Transmitted as Okitsugu's state of mind after his fall (paraphrase)

PRIMARY SOURCES & ARCHIVES

  • PRIMARY

    Tokugawa Jikki

    The shogunate's compiled record of Okitomo's death and Okitsugu's fall

  • SCHOLARSHIP

    The Age of Tanuma Okitsugu

    Ōishi Shinzaburō / Iwanami Shoten

    Examines Okitsugu's fall and his later appraisal

  • ARCHIVE

    Sagara Castle Ruins

    Makinohara City, Shizuoka Prefecture

    The ruins of Okitsugu's castle, confiscated after his fall

    Visit archive →

RELATED REPORTS

END OF FILE -- SA-RPT-tanuma-fall-1788PAGE 1 OF 1